New York woman’s $2 million pain award cut to $1.35 million or new trial ordered

A serious car accident can leave injuries that require major surgery and have lasting effects on a person's life. In New York, a woman who underwent spinal fusion surgery after a collision was initially awarded $2 million for past pain and suffering by a jury. However, the New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department, has ruled that the amount was higher than what could be considered reasonable compensation and ordered a reduction or a new trial on damages.In a November 12, 2026 decision available on Justia, the appeals court modified the earlier ruling in Estela Larrea v.

Sanitation Salvage Corp. et al. The judges vacated the $2 million award and gave Larrea 30 days after entry of the order to accept $1.35 million instead.

If she does not agree, the case will return to court for a new trial limited to those damages. The appeals court otherwise upheld the lower court's decision.Woman underwent cervical spinal fusion surgery after accidentThe case concerned Estela Larrea, who was 60 years old when the appeals court considered her compensation.